☰
"A resolute advocate with a charming manner before the tribunal" Legal 500
“Pragmatic, forthright and intelligent” Legal 500
"A strong advocate who has a no-nonsense approach" Legal 500
"His blunt style is powerful and effective" Legal 500
"Very experienced in public and private children law matters" Legal 500

Cohabitation Disputes

‘I just did not think about what would happen to the house if we split up’

 

Sometimes disputes arise between people who live together but have chosen not to get married. Often how the house will be divided between them was not thought about let alone evidenced legally. Who is entitled to what? How does the court decide?

 

These kinds of disputes are treated differently in law than when a couple are married. Below is a general outline of how the court may approach these kinds of cases.  

 

Other scenarios involve money being provided by a family member to purchase the property to assist with paying the mortgage or renovation work. Do they have an interest in the property? If so what is it? Again, as a third party they may be able to establish an interest in the property – but how?

 

The content of this page is for general information only and should not be treated as a substitute for specific legal advice in relation to your circumstances.

Overview of the Law

 

What can the court do?

 

Essentially, under the Trust of land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 the court has powers to decide if a property should be sold; declare what share of the interest the parties may have or make compensatory orders. The court will look to what the parties intended rather than what is fair.

 

Sometimes it is straightforward, for example, when the parties are both legal owners and signed an express declaration of trust (form TR1) detailing how the interest is to be shared. That being the case the court will not intervene unless it can be established it was a mistake or fraud etc.

 

Otherwise the court is often faced with a number of scenarios:

 

  1. Only one of the parties is a legal owner. The court will usually look to what’s called a constructive trust. This will mean considering the following; what was the common intention of the parties? Whether the person seeking an interest acted to their determent based on that common intention? And whether it would be unconscionable to deny that person an interest?

 

  1. Both parties are legal owners but did not enter into an express declaration of trust or they did but said it was for ‘unequal shares’. Joint legal ownership amounts to a presumed equal beneficial ownership but this can be overcome by demonstrating the parties had a different common intention which they relied on to their detriment. It has been said that there is a ‘heavy burden’ on the party seeking to move away from the equal share presumption.

 

  1. Both parties are legal owners but the property was bought as an investment and not as a home to live in. The court may approach this as what is called a ‘resulting trust’ i.e. the property is shared based on the parties’ financial contribution to it.

 

What’s the interest worth?

 

Once the court has decided that property is held on constructive trust it will then consider quantification. It maybe clear from direct evidence or from a clear inference of what was intended, otherwise the court will look to the whole course of dealings between the parties in relation to the property and decide what is fair. 

 

Intervener claims

 

Normally this involves two parties who agree and one that opposes. An example being that one party says the house in owned by their father (the father agreeing) and the other party disagrees. In that example the opposing party may have no evidence of what the other party and their father claim to have agreed.

 

Essentially the overarching approach is that interests in land should be formally recorded and there will need to be clear evidence that has survived appropriate scrutiny.

Opinions differ on which approach should be taken to start a TOLATA claim based around their being two options. The rules provide for applying via the ‘no substantial dispute of fact’ route (Part 8) or where there is such a dispute of facts (Part 7). Plainly which route to take will depend on the circumstances and expert advice should be sought. 

“Thank you for your help and guidance. It’s difficult to put into words what you have helped me achieve.

 

Thank you for helping bring my family together.”

 

Mr S Ogunyomi (October 2023)

“I cannot recommend John Thornton highly enough. His knowledge, expertise, experience and honesty enables him to successfully navigate a clear path through even the most complex and arduous of cases. I was lucky enough to instruct John on a public access basis. He was able to join my case towards the end of proceedings and with his ability to understand my case rapidly, digest the necessary facts and filter the documentation he successfully protected my children.

 

He is highly skilled in the documentation that he submits to the court. It is precise, factual and demonstrates his extensive knowledge, thus giving the Court a clear direction and basis for decision making. John is both reassuring as well as honest, he quickly instils a sense of trust which is exactly what I needed when walking into this particular hearing. Again, his authority and knowledge of family court law gave me confidence and security, which is often hard in proceedings where you are trying to protect your children. John’s calm, compassionate but focused manner enabled me to feel at ease when discussing my Case with him. John brought clarity and sense to my complex case which also supported the Judge as he too looked to John during this hearing. Don’t hesitate to contact him if you are embarking on a journey with the Family Courts.” 

 

Ms Chapman (December 2023)

“I have to say the John is masterful at his craft, a very professional individual, highly knowledgeable and his attention to detail is TOP NOTCH.

 

He is very honest in his assessments, his approach to his clients are not only professional but also very diligent. When I came across John’s profile online, I instantly knew he could be the perfect representative to take my case forward, but when I met him in person he gave reassurance in my choice. John has an impeccable approach to his work and has the best interest for his clients. He goes a step beyond his duties to make sure his clients are well taken care of.

 

I highly recommend John to anyone who is having family matters at court that require someone who is pragmatic, caring, honest, knowledgeable and very astute in his profession. Thank you John for your work.”

 

Mr E Rivers (March 2024)

“I don’t normally leave reviews, but my experience today in court and with John T representing me was unbelievable. I felt John listen to me and my concerns, read through all the paperwork (there was loads) that was provided and was honest throughout. I had to instruct John at short notice and he really did put the work in, he had a full understanding and his approach was brilliant. Thank you!”

 

Mr D Castello (September 2024)

Memberships