S.25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 is the law set down by parliament that judges must use to decide all cases. Every case is different and so s.25 should always be the touchstone. No one factor in the list set out in s.25 is more important than another although the court must first consider the welfare of any child of the family less than 18 years of age (see link s.25 Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 ). How and when a court can apportion assets in favour of one party over the other is beyond the scope of this synopsis. What can be said though is that the court must be fair i.e. no bias in favour of the “husband as the breadwinner over the wife as the house keeper” or vice versa.
What also needs to be borne in mind by all parties to financial remedy cases is that you are under a duty to provide full and frank disclosure of all relevant information. It is not enough to wait to be asked for the information by your former partner, their lawyer or the judge. The information must be given voluntarily and completely. Failure to do so may result in a costs order being made against you or the court finding your behaviour is so bad that it is reflected in the division of assets at the end of the case.
The content of this page is for general information only and should not be treated as a substitute for specific legal advice in relation to your circumstances.
Proceedings commence with one party providing a notice of application for a financial order by issuing form A: Form A
Please note the requirements in the pre-application protocol for an applicant prior to commencing proceedings to seek out mediation: Practice Direction 9A
The court will then send out to the parties Form C telling the parties when the first appointment (“FA”) will be and the requirements as to filing evidence. This should be done by the court within 4 days of the Form A being issued. The FA hearing should be between 12 and 16 weeks after the date of issue. The court will then serve the respondent within 4 days.
Before the FA the parties must file with the court and simultaneously exchange evidence by completing Form E: Form E (see also Guidance notes Form E guidance notes).
This must be done not less than 35 days before the FA. The form E is a crucial document. In straightforward cases, when full and frank disclosure has taken place, the case could be resolved at the FA by the court treating it as a Financial Dispute Resolution Hearing (“FDR”). Many cases fail to settle early, and thus incur further costs for the parties, because one or both parties have failed to provide full disclosure.
At least 14 days before the FA each party must file at court and serve on the other party:
- Sample Chronology: PDF (writable)
- Sample Concise Statement of Issues: PDF (writable)
- Sample Questionnaire: PDF (writable)
- Form G: PDF (writable)
If you are required to “file and serve” a document or documents by either the rules or by the court this has a specific meaning. To “file” a document essentially means that you must send it to the court in question. This will usually mean by post to the court address but may be by email depending on the court in question. To “serve” a document means to provide the document(s) to the other parties in the case, again this is usually by post but maybe by email and you may need to check with the parties what their preferred option is for service.
So, this is the first hearing before a judge. All the documents above should have been filed and the judge has read all of it in advance. The objective of the court (assisted by the parties) is to identify the issues and save costs. In order to do so the court will also want to know the costs of the parties to date. The following form is required to be completed by the parties: Form H
The judge has wide powers and will endeavour to move the case towards to a fair and swift outcome for the parties. What questions should be answered? What evidence is needed? Can the case be dealt with today as an FDR? The court may decide to list the case on another date for an FDR once the missing evidence is available or list a final hearing or both depending on the facts of the case. If questionnaires are exchanged a date will be set by the court for the parties to reply by.
No later than 7 days before the FDR appointment, the applicant must file at court the details of all offers, proposals and responses. The court will also want at the hearing the parties up-to-date costs estimates.
The purpose of this hearing is to give the parties an opportunity to put their case to the judge and for the judge to give such indications as the circumstances permit. He is not a mediator between the parties however; but the aim is to try and facilitate a settlement. Non-discloser of the content of such meetings is the key to FDR’s working. In other words anything said or admissions made in the course of an FDR appointment cannot be used against you in the future except in exceptional circumstances.
Hearings can take an hour or all day. Parties and lawyers should be at court 1 hour before the stated time to give the process the best chance of working. The rules say that parties attending the appointment must use their best endeavours to reach agreement. The court will thus expect both parties to make and receive offers and to give proper consideration to them. Practice between courts and geographical locations differ widely but the essential purpose is clear.
If the parties are unable to reach agreement then the court has a wide discretion as to what to do next i.e. list another FDR or list a final hearing. The same judge who hears the FDR cannot hear the final hearing. Genuine disputes over the value of significant assets and a perceived failure by one party that the other is not being full and frank often leads to cases not settling at the FDR.
The applicant must not less than 14 days before the hearing file with the court and serve on the other side a concise statement setting out what order he or she seeks. The respondent is obligated to reply within 7 days. These are treated by the court as open offers and will inform the Judge as to what the issues are and what direction the hearing will take. The rules for the preparation of court bundles also must be followed: Practice Direction 27A
The judge will usually hear evidence from the parties and make what are called ‘findings of fact’ on the disputed issues in the case. In other words decide the truth of disputes after hearing the parties give evidence and after considering all the evidence filed. From that the judge will apply the s.25 criteria, and any other relevant law, to the facts and decide on the outcome of the case once each side has had the opportunity to address him in closing submissions. The lawyers will then, usually, draft up the order for the judge to approve whilst still at court. The case has then concluded.
You will not usually get your costs if you are successful at any stage during Financial Remedy cases. The general rules is that each party will bear their own costs. However there are circumstances in which costs can be recovered i.e. a party’s conduct during the proceedings leading to unnecessary costs being incurred by the other party.
“Thank you for your help and guidance. It’s difficult to put into words what you have helped me achieve.
Thank you for helping bring my family together.”
Mr S Ogunyomi (October 2023)
“I cannot recommend John Thornton highly enough. His knowledge, expertise, experience and honesty enables him to successfully navigate a clear path through even the most complex and arduous of cases. I was lucky enough to instruct John on a public access basis. He was able to join my case towards the end of proceedings and with his ability to understand my case rapidly, digest the necessary facts and filter the documentation he successfully protected my children.
He is highly skilled in the documentation that he submits to the court. It is precise, factual and demonstrates his extensive knowledge, thus giving the Court a clear direction and basis for decision making. John is both reassuring as well as honest, he quickly instils a sense of trust which is exactly what I needed when walking into this particular hearing. Again, his authority and knowledge of family court law gave me confidence and security, which is often hard in proceedings where you are trying to protect your children. John’s calm, compassionate but focused manner enabled me to feel at ease when discussing my Case with him. John brought clarity and sense to my complex case which also supported the Judge as he too looked to John during this hearing. Don’t hesitate to contact him if you are embarking on a journey with the Family Courts.”
Ms Chapman (December 2023)
Mr E Rivers (March 2024)“I have to say the John is masterful at his craft, a very professional individual, highly knowledgeable and his attention to detail is TOP NOTCH.
He is very honest in his assessments, his approach to his clients are not only professional but also very diligent. When I came across John’s profile online, I instantly knew he could be the perfect representative to take my case forward, but when I met him in person he gave reassurance in my choice. John has an impeccable approach to his work and has the best interest for his clients. He goes a step beyond his duties to make sure his clients are well taken care of.
I highly recommend John to anyone who is having family matters at court that require someone who is pragmatic, caring, honest, knowledgeable and very astute in his profession. Thank you John for your work.”
“I don’t normally leave reviews, but my experience today in court and with John T representing me was unbelievable. I felt John listen to me and my concerns, read through all the paperwork (there was loads) that was provided and was honest throughout. I had to instruct John at short notice and he really did put the work in, he had a full understanding and his approach was brilliant. Thank you!”
Mr D Castello (September 2024)